Social Cognition
Intent and Outcome Task
Also called: intent-based moral judgment, accidental and attempted harm, moral luck, intention and outcome in moral judgment, belief and outcome stories, judging accidents and attempts
Measure how people weigh intentions against outcomes: participants read short stories in which a person believes an act is harmless or harmful and the act causes harm or none, then rate blame and how acceptable the act was.
6-8 minUntimed
Free to start: 10 free participants per account, then $0.99 per participant for academic research, or any yearly plan. Try it here first, with no account.
- Papers, 2021 to 2025
- 107
- Evidence grade
- D
- Registered clinical studies
- 2
What it measures
Measures how people weigh intentions against outcomes in moral judgment. Participants read 12 short stories in which a person believes an act is harmless or harmful and the act causes harm or none, such as stirring what may be salt into a friend's tea, and rate how much blame the person deserves and how acceptable the act was. The main score is how much more blame attempted harm draws than accidental harm.
Constructs
- Intent-based moral judgment
- Moral luck
- Integrating beliefs and outcomes
- Blame and permissibility
Research uses
- Moral psychology research
- Social cognition and theory of mind research
- Developmental and lifespan research
- Within-study group comparison
How the paradigm works
The intent and outcome task measures how people weigh what someone believed against what happened when they judge an act. Young, Cushman, Hauser and Saxe (2007) wrote stories in four versions: a person believes an act is harmless or harmful, and the act causes harm or none. In their first experiment, 10 students rated each act from 1 (forbidden) to 4 (permissible). Belief mattered most: acts done with a harmful belief averaged 1.1 and those with a harmless belief 3.5. Attempted harm, a harmful belief with no harm done, was judged as forbidden as intentional harm (1.2 and 1.1), while accidental harm was judged less permissible than an act with no harm (3.2 and 3.9). Cushman (2008) crossed belief, desire and consequence over eight situations with 160 visitors per question on the Moral Sense Test website and found that the type of judgment matters: belief explained 62% of the variation in how wrong an act was judged and consequences 3%, while for blame consequences explained 22%. So blame tracks outcomes more than judgments of wrongness or permissibility do. Cushman, Sheketoff, Wharton and Carey (2013) found that among 293 children aged 4 to 8, judging the first story they heard, condemnation of accidental harm fell with age while condemnation of attempted harm did not change. Here each story comes once, in one of its four versions, and is rated for blame and for how acceptable the act was. The main score is the mean blame for attempted harm minus that for accidental harm: positive means what the person believed weighed more than what happened.
Scores
- Attempted Minus Accidental Harm, Blamescore
- Mean blame rating for attempted harm (a harmful belief, no harm done) minus that for accidental harm (a harmless belief, harm done), from -6 to 6.
- Positive means what the person believed weighed more than what happened
- Accidental Minus Attempted Harm, Acceptabilityscore
- Mean acceptability rating of accidental harm minus that of attempted harm, from -6 to 6.
- Positive means attempts were judged less acceptable than accidents
- Belief Effect on Blamescore
- Mean blame rating of the two versions with a harmful belief minus that of the two with a harmless belief, from -6 to 6.
- Positive means a harmful belief drew more blame
- Outcome Effect on Blamescore
- Mean blame rating of the two versions that ended in harm minus that of the two that did not, from -6 to 6.
- Positive means harm done drew more blame
- Belief Effect on Acceptabilityscore
- Mean acceptability rating of the two versions with a harmless belief minus that of the two with a harmful belief, from -6 to 6.
- Positive means a harmful belief made the act less acceptable
- Outcome Effect on Acceptabilityscore
- Mean acceptability rating of the two versions with no harm minus that of the two that ended in harm, from -6 to 6.
- Positive means harm done made the act less acceptable
- Blame, No Harm Believed or Donescore
- Mean blame rating, from 1 to 7, for stories with a harmless belief and no harm.
- Informational
- Blame, Accidental Harmscore
- Mean blame rating, from 1 to 7, for stories with a harmless belief and harm done.
- Informational
- Blame, Attempted Harmscore
- Mean blame rating, from 1 to 7, for stories with a harmful belief and no harm done.
- Informational
- Blame, Intentional Harmscore
- Mean blame rating, from 1 to 7, for stories with a harmful belief and harm done.
- Informational
- Acceptability, No Harm Believed or Donescore
- Mean acceptability rating, from 1 to 7, for stories with a harmless belief and no harm.
- Informational
- Acceptability, Accidental Harmscore
- Mean acceptability rating, from 1 to 7, for stories with a harmless belief and harm done.
- Informational
- Acceptability, Attempted Harmscore
- Mean acceptability rating, from 1 to 7, for stories with a harmful belief and no harm done.
- Informational
- Acceptability, Intentional Harmscore
- Mean acceptability rating, from 1 to 7, for stories with a harmful belief and harm done.
- Informational
- Median Reading Timems
- Median time spent on a story screen before pressing Next.
- Informational
- Median Rating Timems
- Median time from a rating screen appearing to a rating, over ratings at or after 100 ms.
- Informational
- Ratings Under 100 mscount
- Ratings made less than 100 ms after their screen appeared.
- 0 expected
- Stories Ratedcount
- Story screens rated on both questions.
- Informational
Use and evidence
107 papers from 2021 to 2025 name this task in their title or abstract, up 32% compared with 2016 to 2020. That ranks it 271 of 711 test families in our census. See the counts for every test.
Show the numbers
| Year | Papers |
|---|---|
| 2025 | 22 |
| 2024 | 23 |
| 2023 | 15 |
| 2022 | 21 |
| 2021 | 26 |
| 2020 | 11 |
| 2019 | 18 |
| 2018 | 17 |
| 2017 | 18 |
| 2016 | 17 |
| 2015 | 7 |
| 2014 | 9 |
| 2013 | 9 |
| 2012 | 8 |
| 2011 | 6 |
| 2010 | 4 |
| 2009 | 6 |
| 2008 | 3 |
| 2007 | 3 |
| 2006 | 2 |
| 2005 | 4 |
| 2004 | 4 |
| 2003 | 3 |
| 2002 | 3 |
| 2001 | 3 |
| 2000 | 1 |
Use grade C
100 to 299 papers from 2021 to 2025.
Evidence grade D
Little published measurement evidence found.
- Papers on test-retest reliability
- 0
- Papers on reliability or validity
- 9
- Registered clinical studies using it as an outcome
- 2
Measured on ConductCognition
Pooled across the studies that feed our platform norms, by device group. A figure needs 50 or more people.
No pooled figure yet.
Note on the counts: also counts mentions of accidental harm outside moral judgment.
How the grades work
Use: A is 1,000 or more papers from 2021 to 2025, B 300 to 999, C 100 to 299, D 30 to 99 and E fewer than 30. Evidence: A means at least 25 papers report its test-retest reliability and at least 25 registered clinical studies use it as an outcome; B, at least 8 test-retest papers, and either 5 registered clinical studies or 150 reliability or validity papers; C, at least 2 test-retest papers, 30 reliability or validity papers or 3 registered clinical studies; D, little published measurement evidence found. The counts measure use. They include every paper that names the task in its title or abstract. Grades describe the published research on this task, not ConductCognition's version of it.
Source: ConductCognition test census 0.58.0, counted 14 November 2026 from OpenAlex and ClinicalTrials.gov.
Task design
The trial sequence as the test runs in ConductCognition.
- Stories
- 12 written for this task, each an everyday act that affects someone else's things or plans, such as stirring what may be salt into a friend's tea. Each comes in four versions: the person believes the act is harmless or harmful, and it causes harm or none. None has political, religious, group, health or injury content, and none is a published story. They are shown in the session's language.
- Ratings
- After each story, two screens: how much blame the person deserves, from 1 (none at all) to 7 (very much), and how acceptable the act was, from 1 (not at all) to 7 (completely), on seven buttons. A check with feedback first makes sure people know what they rate.
- Order
- 12 stories as standard, or the first 8. Each story comes once, in an order drawn from the session's seed, and the four versions come in blocks of four, so each comes equally often and never twice in a row.
- Scores
- Attempted minus accidental harm: the mean blame for attempted harm minus that for accidental harm, from -6 to 6. Also the same contrast for acceptability, the effects of belief and of outcome on each rating, and the eight means behind them.
Young and colleagues (2007) found attempted harm judged as forbidden as intentional harm, while accidental harm was only partly excused, and Cushman (2008) found blame tracks outcomes more than judgments of wrongness or permissibility do. This task uses their method with stories of its own, none from either source. Scores describe how a person weighs intentions against outcomes and are best compared between groups; they do not diagnose.
Quality checks
Each session is marked valid, needs review or invalid, with the reason, before you see its scores.
Scored rows: the scored run's ratings of the stories. No rating is correct, so accuracy is not judged against chance. A run with no story of attempted harm or none of accidental harm rated for blame, or with fewer than half the stories rated on both questions, is invalid, and any other shortfall is flagged; one number chosen for at least 90% of the ratings is flagged. Ratings under 200 ms on at least half the screens invalidate.
Why these rules
There is no correct option to compare with chance, so accuracy is not judged against chance. The scores describe how much what a person believed and what happened move ratings of blame and acceptability, so any rating is a possible answer. The main score needs stories of attempted and of accidental harm rated. One number for nearly every rating suggests the scale was not used; it is flagged for review because it can also be a real answer. An answer under 200 ms is faster than a simple visual reaction, so it cannot reflect the item. Following response-time effort screening for untimed tests (Wise and Kong 2005), the session is invalid only when at least half the answers are that fast.
No percentile. Scores and quality flags only.
Running this test
Settings you can change
| Setting | Standard | Allowed |
|---|---|---|
| Stories | 12 stories (standard) | 8 stories, 12 stories (standard) |
Yearly plans can change settings within these limits. Free and pay-as-you-go studies use the standard settings.
Need a setting this test does not have?
Devices and languages
- Untimed test: runs on desktops, laptops, tablets and phones. Participant devices
- Languages: English, Spanish, French, German, Italian, Portuguese (Brazil), Chinese (Simplified) and Japanese.
- Available on: Every plan, including the free plan.
- No percentile. Scores and quality flags only. How norms work
- Recruiting online? See the setup guides for Prolific, Sona Systems, CloudResearch Connect and Qualtrics.
Cite and describe
Participants completed the Intent and Outcome Task in a web browser (ConductCognition task version 1.0.0, scoring version 1.0.0; Young L, Cushman F, Hauser M, Saxe R, 2007; Cushman F, 2008), with the standard settings (stories: 12 stories). The main score was attempted minus accidental Harm, blame (mean blame rating for attempted harm (a harmful belief, no harm done) minus that for accidental harm (a harmless belief, harm done), from -6 to 6).
ConductCognition versions: task version 1.0.0, scoring version 1.0.0. Every export records the versions each session used, for a methods section.
- Young, L., Cushman, F., Hauser, M., & Saxe, R. (2007). The neural basis of the interaction between theory of mind and moral judgment. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 104(20), 8235-8240. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0701408104
- Cushman, F. (2008). Crime and punishment: Distinguishing the roles of causal and intentional analyses in moral judgment. Cognition, 108(2), 353-380. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cognition.2008.03.006Blame and punishment tracked outcomes more than wrongness and permissibility did, with 160 participants per question.
- Young, L., & Saxe, R. (2008). The neural basis of belief encoding and integration in moral judgment. NeuroImage, 40(4), 1912-1920. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2008.01.05748 scenarios crossing a harmful or harmless belief with a harmful or harmless outcome; 17 participants judged one version of each.
- Cushman, F., Sheketoff, R., Wharton, S., & Carey, S. (2013). The development of intent-based moral judgment. Cognition, 127(1), 6-21. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cognition.2012.11.008Judgments of accidental and attempted harm in 293 children aged 4 to 8.
Source papers
- Young and colleagues (2007), first experiment: 10 students rated acts from 1 (forbidden) to 4 (permissible); no harm believed or done 3.9, accidental harm 3.2, attempted harm 1.2, intentional harm 1.1.Paradigm source, Adults
Questions
How long does the Intent and Outcome Task take?
About 6 to 8 minutes, as listed in the test library.
What device does a participant need?
Untimed test: runs on desktops, laptops, tablets and phones. The browser must be Chrome, Edge, Firefox or Safari.
What scores does it produce?
Attempted Minus Accidental Harm, Blame, Accidental Minus Attempted Harm, Acceptability, Belief Effect on Blame, Outcome Effect on Blame, Belief Effect on Acceptability, Outcome Effect on Acceptability, Blame, No Harm Believed or Done, Blame, Accidental Harm, Blame, Attempted Harm, Blame, Intentional Harm, Acceptability, No Harm Believed or Done, Acceptability, Accidental Harm, Acceptability, Attempted Harm, Acceptability, Intentional Harm, Median Reading Time, Median Rating Time, Ratings Under 100 ms and Stories Rated. Each session is also marked valid, needs review or invalid, with the reason.
How widely is the Intent and Outcome Task used in research?
107 papers from 2021 to 2025 name it in their title or abstract, up 32% compared with 2016 to 2020. That ranks it 271 of 711 test families in the ConductCognition test census (use grade C). Source: ConductCognition test census 0.58.0, counted 14 November 2026 from OpenAlex and ClinicalTrials.gov.
How much reliability evidence does the Intent and Outcome Task have?
In the published research, 0 papers report its test-retest reliability and 2 registered clinical studies use it as an outcome (evidence grade D in the ConductCognition test census).
Does it report a percentile?
No. Scores and quality flags only.
Which settings can a researcher change?
Stories (8 stories, 12 stories (standard)). Settings can be changed on yearly plans; free and pay-as-you-go studies use the standard settings.
Which languages can participants use?
Participants can take this test in English, Spanish, French, German, Italian, Portuguese (Brazil), Chinese (Simplified) and Japanese, with its words in the same language. English is on every plan, and the other languages come with yearly plans. Have a native speaker read the machine-translated text before launch.
Is this a clinical test?
No. ConductCognition is for research use only. It runs, scores and exports the test; clinical interpretation is outside the platform.
Every test: the full test list.
Run this test in your next study
Start free with 10 free participants on any test, then use participant credits or a yearly plan.